How to move Memberful subscribers to Whop without double billing
Quick answer
Memberful charges the cards in your Stripe on its own schedule, so Whop Migrations finds no subscriptions and every paying member re-subscribes. Give each one a Whop trial that ends on their Memberful expiration date. Then turn off their Memberful auto-renew with Bulk edit subscriptions, which accepts up to 10,000 pasted emails, before that date. They keep Memberful access until it expires, and nobody is charged twice.
Let your AI agent do the busywork
Paste the prompt into any AI agent and it moves your Memberful business to Whop, with you approving each step.
On this page
- Why every paying member has to re-subscribe
- How Memberful bills your members today
- Step 1: Export and sort your members
- Step 2: Create Whop plans whose trials end on Memberful renewal dates
- Step 3: Turn off retention discounts for the switch
- Step 4: Announce with each member's own date
- Step 5: Turn off auto-renew for members who've joined
- Step 6: Fix a double charge if it happens
- Step 7: Close Memberful in the right order
- Troubleshooting
- What you can't avoid
- Finish: your subscribers paying on Whop
- FAQ
- Sources
We built MoveToWhop, the free migration tool this guide uses, and we may earn a referral commission from Whop if you create a Whop through our links. It costs you nothing. Memberful's billing rules below are from its docs, checked October 14, 2026.
A member only pays twice when Memberful renews them after their Whop billing has started. So the job is two things: make each member's first Whop charge land on the day Memberful would have charged them, and turn off their Memberful auto-renew before that day. This guide covers the Memberful side of both. The full Memberful to Whop plan covers fees, plans and when switching makes sense.
Why every paying member has to re-subscribe
Memberful's docs say it manages member subscriptions inside Memberful, stores the cards with Stripe, and charges each card in Stripe when a renewal is due. So the cards are in your Stripe account, but the subscriptions aren't. When Memberful imports members from another tool, it even deletes their Stripe subscriptions to avoid double charges.
Whop's own migration feature, Whop Migrations, moves active and trialing card subscriptions out of a Stripe account you own (Whop blog, June 2026). With no Stripe subscriptions behind your Memberful members, there's nothing for it to move.
Check before you plan: in your Stripe Dashboard, open Billing, then Subscriptions. If your Memberful members aren't listed there as active subscriptions, every paying member re-subscribes on Whop through a personal link, and you turn off their Memberful auto-renew.
How Memberful bills your members today
Billing rules as of October 2026. Sources at the end of this page.
| Situation | What Memberful does | What it means for the switch |
|---|---|---|
| Auto-renew on | Charges the card in your Stripe on the expiration date | Their Whop trial ends that day |
| Auto-renew off | No more charges; access until the expiration date | Nothing to stop. Invite them before access ends |
| Renewal declined | Emails the member, retries up to 4 times 12 hours apart, and deactivates the subscription after 48 hours | No paid time to cover, so they pay when they join Whop |
| Gift | The buyer paid for one term; the recipient adds a card before the next renewal, with a reminder a week before | Decide between a free link and a paid one |
| Externally paid group | Never charged by card; you record wire or cheque payments, at $0.20 a month per seat | Agree billing with the group manager directly |
| One-time purchase | No renewal | A free claim link to the same product |
Step 1: Export and sort your members
Export All members with a custom date range that starts before your first member. The default range covers recent members only. Our Memberful export guide walks through it, plus the orders export you'll use for prices.
Then sort the file into these groups. Each one gets a different message:
| Group | How to spot it | What they get on Whop | What to tell them |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auto-renewing members | Active, Auto-renew on | A hidden plan at their price, free until their Memberful renewal | Join, then cancel on Memberful |
| Already cancelled | Active, Auto-renew off | Nothing automatic: the tool leaves them out | Here's the new home, for when your access ends |
| Annual members | An expiration date months away | The same, with a trial of up to a year | Nothing to pay until your renewal; cancel on Memberful now |
| Coupon or custom-amount members | The Coupon column, or a lower amount in the orders export | A hidden plan at their own amount, if you add a Price column with it | What they'll pay on Whop, and for how long |
| Externally paid groups | The External payments column | The tool doesn't read that column, so an auto-renewing row gets a card trial plan like anyone else's: leave them out of the mail merge | A direct conversation with the group manager |
Step 2: Create Whop plans whose trials end on Memberful renewal dates
Open the free Memberful migration tool, tap Memberful and drop your member CSV. Memberful's export has no prices, so enter each plan's price and billing period in Review; the orders export shows what each plan costs. When you press Move to Whop, the tool creates a hidden "existing members" plan at each price, with a free trial set so that a member who joins on move day is first charged on their Memberful expiration date.
Here's that part in the wizard, prices included (about 20 seconds, test data, no sound):
Details that matter:
- The trial is a number of days, counted from the day a member joins. Joining later never makes anyone pay early; it only pushes their first Whop charge later. That's why you send links the day you move.
- Up to 8 renewal dates per price are matched exactly. Beyond that, trials are rounded up to a few set lengths, so some members get a few extra free days rather than an early charge.
- Annual members get long trials. In our test, a member renewing March 12 got a 149-day trial on October 14.
- Mixed monthly and yearly prices need a fix first. One Memberful plan can hold several prices, but the export only names the plan. A plan whose name doesn't say Annual or Yearly is treated as monthly, so after their trial a yearly member would be billed monthly. Rename their Plan cell (say, "Membership (Annual)") or set the billing period in Review.
- Each hidden plan has limited stock: its member count, plus one spare per 50 members, so a forwarded link can't be claimed by everyone.
Each member claims access through their link, because Whop's API has no way to add members directly ("checkout does that for you," per Whop's developer docs).
Step 3: Turn off retention discounts for the switch
If you use Memberful's retention discounts, a member who cancels is offered a discount to stay: in the cancellation step, by email an hour later, or both. That's the opposite of what you want while members move.
In Memberful, go to Revenue, then Retention, and turn off both the in-app and email offers for your switching window. New accounts start with both off, so check rather than assume.
Step 4: Announce with each member's own date
Each member's deadline is their own Memberful expiration date. The Done screen's member file has it as each member's first Whop charge date, next to their link, so you can merge both into your email.
Tell every auto-renewing member four things:
- Their link, and that Whop won't charge them until their Memberful renewal date.
- Cancel on Memberful right after joining:
https://youraccount.memberful.com/account/subscriptions, then Cancel subscription. They keep access until their paid time runs out. - Unsubscribing from your emails doesn't cancel. Memberful's docs are clear that a newsletter unsubscribe link doesn't touch the subscription.
- Annual members: nothing to pay on Whop until the renewal, but cancel on Memberful now.
MoveToWhop doesn't send email for you. The Done screen copies an invite email for your own mail tool, and our announcement templates cover the full send timeline. Use version B, the one for members who re-join.
Step 5: Turn off auto-renew for members who've joined
Don't rely on members cancelling themselves. Memberful's bulk edit takes a pasted list of emails, so you can stop renewals for exactly the people who've moved.
- In Memberful, go to Members, then Subscriptions, then Bulk edit subscriptions.
- Select all plans, and set Auto-renew status to Enabled.
- Under Refine results by email (optional), click the edit icon next to Any member, paste the emails of members who've joined Whop (up to 10,000, separated by commas, spaces or new lines) and click Apply. Memberful shows how many matched.
- Choose Disable auto-renew.
- Click Update subscription, type
CONFIRM, then click Confirm.
Disable auto-renew cancels each subscription at its next renewal date. Members keep access until it expires and aren't notified. Don't use Delete subscription: it removes access at once.
Do this every day or two during the window. Each morning, filter by Date of expiration for the coming 7 days with Auto-renew Enabled, and compare that list with the members who've joined (your Whop dashboard's Users page). Anyone on both lists renews on Memberful soon. At your deadline, run the bulk edit once more for everyone still renewing, with no email filter.
Step 6: Fix a double charge if it happens
It's cheaper to refund one charge than to lose a member over it.
- Refund on Memberful: open the member's profile, select the Activity tab, click the Order #, then Refund order. You can refund all or part of it, and cancel the subscription in the same step. Memberful keeps its 4.9% fee on refunded orders.
- Or give the time back on Whop: in your Whop dashboard, open Users, then Memberships, use the three-dot menu and choose Add free days. That moves the member's next Whop charge date.
Step 7: Close Memberful in the right order
When your window ends:
- End external payments. For each externally paid group, cancel the subscription and turn off Enable external payments. Memberful's docs say the $0.20 monthly seat fee continues otherwise.
- Check Discord. If Memberful manages your server, switch its access setting to All members before cancelled subscriptions start expiring. Our Memberful Discord guide explains why.
- Take final exports: members, subscriptions, orders, activity and cancellations.
- Keep your Memberful plan paid until the last step. If your $49 payment fails, Memberful's fee rises from 4.9% to 12.5% and you can no longer email posts.
- Close last: as the account owner, go to Settings and click Close Account at the bottom. Memberful deletes all of the account's data when you do.
Troubleshooting
| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| A member was charged by Memberful and Whop in the same week | Their auto-renew was still on at their expiration date | Refund the Memberful order, or add free days on Whop |
| A member says Whop charged them on day one | They joined through your public plan, not their link | Refund on Whop, and resend their own link |
| A member who cancelled was offered a discount | Retention discounts are on | Revenue, then Retention: turn off in-app and email |
| Bulk edit matched fewer emails than you pasted | They used a different email on Whop, or another plan wasn't selected | Select all plans, then find the rest by name |
| A yearly member's Whop plan is monthly | Their plan's name didn't say Annual or Yearly | Fix the billing period on that plan before they claim it |
| Members lost Discord when their Memberful subscription expired | Memberful's Discord setting removes lapsed members | Switch it to All members; see the Discord guide |
What you can't avoid
- Some members won't move. Plan for it in your numbers, and keep your final export.
- Memberful's fee on the last renewals. Members renewing on Memberful before they move pay Memberful as usual, and you pay its 4.9% on those.
- Nobody can cancel for your members except you or them. MoveToWhop never asks for your Memberful login or API key; the bulk edit above is the clean way to do it yourself.
Finish: your subscribers paying on Whop
With dates lined up and retention offers off, the move itself is short: export, enter prices, Move to Whop, send links, then disable auto-renew for everyone who joins. Want the numbers first? At $5,000 a month with a $15 average charge, our fee calculator puts Memberful at $539 a month and Whop at $260, before payout fees and any Discord app fee; run your own in the Memberful vs Whop fee calculator.
Prefer an AI assistant? Connect MoveToWhop's free read-only MCP server (https://movetowhop.com/mcp) and ask it for a Memberful plan; our Memberful AI migration guide has the prompt. Or start your free Memberful migration now.
Frequently asked questions
Will my members be charged twice when I move from Memberful to Whop?
Not if their Whop trial ends on their Memberful expiration date and their Memberful auto-renew is off before that date. For an auto-renewing subscription, the expiration date is when Memberful would charge next, so the first Whop charge replaces a Memberful charge instead of adding to it.
Can Whop Migrations move my Memberful subscribers with their cards?
Not in a standard Memberful setup. Whop Migrations moves active and trialing card subscriptions from a Stripe account you own. Memberful stores cards as Stripe customers but runs the renewals itself, so there are no Stripe subscriptions to find. Check Billing, then Subscriptions, in your Stripe Dashboard to be sure.
Does turning off auto-renew cut off a member's access?
No. Memberful's Disable auto-renew cancels a subscription at its next renewal date, and the member keeps access until it expires. Deleting a subscription is different: it removes access at once, so don't use it for the switch.
Are members told when I bulk edit their subscriptions?
No. Memberful's docs say members aren't notified about bulk edits, so your own announcement has to explain the switch. If you turned on retention discounts, members who cancel themselves may be offered one, so turn them off for the switching window.
What happens to annual members?
Their Whop trial runs to their Memberful expiration date, which can be months away, so they don't pay Whop until their Memberful year is used up. In our test, a member renewing next March 12 got a 149-day trial. Turn off their Memberful auto-renew once they've joined, as for monthly members.
Can I refund a member who was charged twice?
Yes. In Memberful, open the member's profile, then the Activity tab, click the order number and choose Refund order. Memberful keeps its 4.9% fee on refunds. Or add free days to their Whop membership, which moves their next Whop charge date.
Sources
Last updated . Prices and fees checked . Plans change, so confirm on the official page before you buy.
- 1.Memberful docs: Payment processing, subscriptions managed in Memberful and cards charged in Stripe (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 2.Memberful docs: Import members with existing Stripe Subscriptions, which Memberful deletes (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 3.Memberful docs: Bulk edit member subscriptions, email filter and Disable auto-renew (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 4.Memberful docs: Modify a member's subscription, cancel versus delete (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 5.Memberful docs: How members manage their subscriptions (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 6.Memberful docs: How we handle failed payments, four retries over 48 hours (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 7.Memberful docs: Offer retention discounts, in-app and email offers (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 8.Memberful docs: Refund or suspend an order (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 9.Memberful docs: Accept external payments, $0.20 per seat until turned off (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 10.Memberful docs: Offer and manage gifts (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 11.Memberful docs: The right way to unsubscribe (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 12.Memberful docs: Manage your account in live mode, 12.5% fee after a failed account payment (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 13.Memberful docs: Close your account (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 14.Memberful pricing page, $49 a month plus 4.9% (checked 2026-10-14)memberful.com
- 15.Whop blog: Whop Migrations, Stripe card subscriptions only (published 2026-06-17, checked 2026-10-14)whop.com
- 16.Whop Docs: Fees, 2.7% + $0.30 domestic cards, 0.5% billing when enabled (checked 2026-10-14)docs.whop.com
- 17.Stripe pricing, 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card charge (checked 2026-10-14)stripe.com
- 18.Whop app listing: Discord, 3% fee notice (checked 2026-10-14)whop.com
- 19.Whop Docs: Manage users, Add free days (checked 2026-10-14)docs.whop.com
- 20.Whop Docs: Memberships developer guide, checkout creates memberships (checked 2026-10-14)docs.whop.com
What changed
- First published. Memberful's billing, bulk edit, retention, refund and closing rules checked in its docs on October 14, 2026; trial lengths tested with MoveToWhop CLI 0.1.0.
Keep reading
Related guides and comparisons
Memberful to Whop
Memberful bills members itself, so Whop's Stripe migration has nothing to move. Export first, rebuild your plans, line up trials and keep Discord roles working.
Export Memberful members
Memberful's member export defaults to the last 30 days and has no price column. How to export everyone, what all 31 columns hold and how to move them to Whop.
Transfer subscriptions to Whop
Whop Migrations moves active and trialing Stripe card subscriptions of $1+ with renewal dates kept. Skool, Patreon and Kajabi Payments members re-subscribe.
Migration announcement templates
Copy-paste emails, DMs and posts for telling members you're moving to Whop, from 14 days out to after the deadline, with Stripe and re-subscribe versions.
Memberful Discord to Whop
Memberful's bot can kick or strip roles from members who stop paying on Memberful. Give Whop its own roles, switch to All members, and handle Discourse too.
Whop Fees Explained
Whop takes 2.7% + $0.30 per domestic card sale (3.2% + $0.30 on subscriptions with billing on) and no monthly fee. Fees sourced, with math at $1k to $50k.
Bet on yourself. Move to Whop.
Free migration. Takes minutes. Keep your members, courses and revenue.