6 Best Circle Alternatives in 2026: The Buyer's Shortlist
MoveToWhop is independent and not affiliated with Whop, Inc. or any platform we cover. We may earn a referral commission from Whop when you create a Whop through our links. It never costs you anything, and it's how we keep migrations free. We don't earn commissions from the other platforms on this page. How we make money
Quick answer
Heartbeat is the best Circle alternative for most paid communities in 2026, scoring 70.8 of 100 on our published criteria: it has every community feature Circle has, imports your Stripe subscriptions for free, and costs about $9,003 a year at $10,000 a month in $49 memberships, against $8,643 on Circle Professional. Mighty Networks (67.2), Skool (63.6), Whop (62.4), Kajabi and Discord follow. Prices checked October 14, 2026.
Disclosure: We built MoveToWhop, a free tool that moves creator businesses to Whop, and we earn a referral commission from Whop when you sign up through our links. We earn nothing from the other platforms on this list. Whop ranks fourth on the criteria below even though it costs the least, our own tool isn't part of any score, and the weights and the order they produce are published in full. How we make money
Free calculatorSee your take-home on Whop vs CircleYour price and revenue, every fee itemized. No signup.Let your AI agent do the busywork
Paste the prompt into any AI agent and it moves your Circle business to Whop, with you approving each step.
Circle alternatives at a glance
Prices and fees as of October 2026, from each company's public pricing pages. Details for each option are further down this page.
| Platform | Best for | Price | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heartbeat | Best forAn all-in-one community under 5,000 members that imports your Stripe subscriptions | Price$49, $149 or $849/mo (Build, Grow, Scale) | Fees5%, 2.5% or 1.25% by plan, plus Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ |
| Mighty Networks | Best forA Circle-style network built around live cohorts and events | Price$35, $95, $215 or $425/mo (Explore, Launch, Scale, Growth) | Fees5%, 2%, 1% or 0.5% by plan, plus Stripe processing |
| Skool | Best forSimple, gamified groups with sales tax handled | Price$9/mo (Hobby) or $99/mo (Pro) | FeesHobby 10% + 30¢; Pro 2.9% + 30¢ (3.9% on charges above $900), processing included |
| Whop | Best forThe lowest cost, with Circle's Stripe subscribers moved across | Price$0/mo | Fees2.7% + 30¢ per US card sale, +0.5% Billing fee on subscriptions when enabled |
| Kajabi | Best forA community next to courses, email marketing and funnels | Price$179, $249 or $499/mo (Basic, Growth, Pro) | FeesKajabi Payments 2.9% to 2.7% + 30¢, +0.7% on subscriptions |
| Discord Server Subscriptions | Best forUS owners whose members already live in Discord | Price$0/mo | FeesAbout 15.4% of each desktop or web payment (6% processing, then 10%) |
On this page
- At a glance
- Key takeaways
- What a Circle alternative actually is (and what it isn't)
- Why creators look for Circle alternatives
- How we ranked these Circle alternatives
- The best Circle alternatives in 2026
- 1. Heartbeat, best for an all-in-one community that imports your subscriptions
- 2. Mighty Networks, best for live cohorts and events
- 3. Skool, best for simple, gamified groups with tax handled
- 4. Whop, best for the lowest cost with your Stripe subscribers moved
- 5. Kajabi, best for community plus email marketing and funnels
- 6. Discord Server Subscriptions, best for groups that live in Discord
- Side-by-side comparison
- What a year costs on each platform
- Which Circle alternative fits your use case
- What results look like: a worked example
- When Circle is the better choice
- Move to Whop free (no passwords)
- FAQ
- Sources
Key takeaways
- Heartbeat scores highest, 70.8 out of 100. It matches all six community features Circle has and is the only alternative here with a free, self-serve import of your existing Stripe subscriptions that also keeps the cards in a Stripe account you own.
- Whop costs the least but ranks fourth. At $10,000 a month in $49 memberships, a year costs about $4,575 on Whop, $5,403 on Skool Pro, $7,755 on Mighty Networks and $8,643 on Circle Professional (prices checked October 14, 2026). Whop loses points for having no native points or leaderboards and for keeping members' cards.
- Circle isn't the most expensive option. Heartbeat costs more than Circle Professional at $10,000 a month ($9,003), because Grow's 2.5% fee outweighs the lower plan price, and Discord Server Subscriptions takes about 15.4% of every payment.
- Where your Stripe subscribers can go without new cards: Heartbeat (self-serve import), Whop (Whop's Stripe migration) and Kajabi (on request, into Kajabi Payments). On Mighty Networks, Skool and Discord, paying members re-subscribe.
- Only Skool and Discord take sales tax off your hands by default. Circle collects tax at checkout through Stripe Tax and leaves filing to you; so do Heartbeat, Mighty Networks and Kajabi, and Whop charges 2% to remit.
Want the numbers for your own price and revenue? The creator fee calculator runs the same math on any Circle plan.
What a Circle alternative actually is (and what it isn't)
Circle is a community platform for creators and brands: discussion spaces, chat, courses, events, live streams and gamification, with iOS, Android and desktop apps, on every plan. Professional costs $99 a month with a 2% transaction fee, Business $219 with 1% and Scale $419 with 1% ($89, $199 and $419 billed yearly), and Circle Plus is custom-priced at 0.5% with branded apps. Payments run through your own Stripe account, so Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ and its 0.7% Billing fee on subscriptions apply, with Circle's fee on top.
Circle isn't a marketplace, it doesn't remit sales tax, and email marketing is an add-on: Email Hub costs $99 a month for 10,000 contacts.
For this page, a Circle alternative is a platform that can charge for community access and run the community itself, or gate it in an app your members already use. We left out platforms that can't take payments, such as free forum software and brand-community tools.
Why creators look for Circle alternatives
Most of the reasons come back to cost and lock-in.
- The entry price went up. In February 2025 Circle's pricing page still listed a Basic plan at $39 a month billed yearly; today the cheapest plan is Professional at $89 billed yearly or $99 month to month.
- Fees stack. Professional takes 2% of each paywall sale on top of Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ and Stripe Billing's 0.7%, so a subscription charge pays 5.6% + 30¢ before the plan price.
- Add-ons are metered. Email Hub is priced by contacts, extra admins cost $10 a month each, storage overages have been billed since November 15, 2025, and extra Circle AI credits since July 29, 2026.
- Leaving takes planning. Circle disconnects Stripe only after active subscriptions are cancelled, and the full posts-and-comments export comes from support without uploaded media.
The full breakdown of Circle's pricing lists every plan and fee with dates.
How we ranked these Circle alternatives
We scored each platform from 0 to 100 on four objective criteria, using one community: members paying $49 a month by US card.
| Criterion | Weight | How we measured it |
|---|---|---|
| Yearly cost | 40% | Plan price plus every per-charge fee at $1,000, $10,000 and $50,000 a month in sales, on the cheapest plan that fits the member count |
| Circle features covered | 30% | A forum or feed, group chat, courses, native live video, points or badges, and a member app, on any plan |
| Sales tax handling | 15% | 1 if the platform collects and remits tax by default, 0.5 if it collects at checkout but you file (or remitting is a paid opt-in), 0 if nothing is built in |
| Moving paying members | 15% | 0.5 for a documented way to take over Circle's Stripe subscriptions, 0.5 for cards sitting in a Stripe account you own afterwards |
Each criterion is rescaled so the lowest platform scores 0 and the highest 100 (cost at each sales level, then averaged), then weighted and added. Our own migration tool isn't part of any score.
The weights are a judgment call. With all four criteria at 25%, Heartbeat still leads (66.1), Skool moves to second (58.5), Mighty Networks third (56.0), Kajabi fourth and Whop fifth (49.9). Discord's very high cost stretches the cost scale, which narrows the gaps between everyone else on that criterion.
What we didn't measure: how good each community feels, moderation tools, support or uptime. Every price comes from the company's own pricing page, checked October 14, 2026. We re-check prices at least every 30 days and log changes at the bottom of the page.
Scores from the formula
Computed when this page is built, from the weights and measurements above, so no entry is placed by hand. The last column ranks the same measurements with every criterion weighted equally (25% each).
| Rank | Option | Score | Equal weights |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Heartbeat | 70.8 | #1 (66.1) |
| 2 | Mighty Networks | 67.2 | #3 (56) |
| 3 | Skool | 63.6 | #2 (58.5) |
| 4 | Whop | 62.4 | #5 (49.9) |
| 5 | Kajabi | 60.7 | #4 (52) |
| 6 | Discord Server Subscriptions | 19.9 | #6 (28.1) |
With equal weights, Whop isn't first: Heartbeat is, and Whop ranks 5th (49.9).
The best Circle alternatives in 2026
Here's the order our scores produce. Heartbeat and Mighty Networks are the closest swaps for Circle's feature set. Skool, Whop and Kajabi each give up one thing, group chat, points or price, for something else.
1. Heartbeat, best for an all-in-one community that imports your subscriptions
Heartbeat is a community platform with discussions, chat channels, courses, events, voice and video rooms and its own checkout. It says 40,000+ businesses and creators use it.
Build costs $49 a month with a 5% fee for up to 350 members, Grow $149 at 2.5% for up to 5,000, and Scale $849 at 1.25% with no cap ($40, $124 and $766 billed yearly). Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ comes on top. Our $49 memberships cost $1,609 a year at $1,000 a month on Build, then $9,003 and $37,861 on Grow: $360 more than Circle Professional at $10,000 and $3,960 more than Circle Business at $50,000.
Our score: 70.8 (cost 64.5, Circle features 100, sales tax 0, moving 100).
Where it's strong:
- All six Circle features we checked, with courses that run evergreen, on drip or as cohorts, voice and video rooms for 256 people, and badges awarded automatically for posts, comments, logins or attendance.
- A free, self-serve tool imports your existing Stripe subscriptions, and payments run through a Heartbeat-managed Stripe business inside your own Stripe account. Its pricing page also lists a Circle import.
- Unlimited admins and moderators, where Circle includes 3 on Professional and charges $10 a month for each extra.
Where it falls short:
- Member caps count admins: 350 on Build and 5,000 on Grow. Unlimited members means Scale at $849 a month.
- Above about $2,200 a month in $49 memberships it costs more than Circle at every level we priced, because Build's 5% and Grow's 2.5% outweigh the lower plan prices.
- Native video hosting starts on Grow or costs $19 a month on Build, and Stripe Tax collects on memberships only, with filing left to you.
Best suited for: communities of a few hundred to a few thousand members that want Circle's tools and their own Stripe, with the move made easy.
2. Mighty Networks, best for live cohorts and events
Mighty Networks is the closest match to Circle's shape: spaces, courses, events and livestreams in one network, with member apps.
Explore costs $35 a month with a 5% fee and no courses, Launch $95 at 2%, Scale $215 at 1% and Growth $425 at 0.5% ($29, $79, $179 and $354 yearly). Stripe processing comes on top. Our memberships cost $1,441 a year at $1,000 a month on Explore, $7,755 at $10,000 on Launch and $29,173 at $50,000 on Growth: less than Circle at every level.
Our score: 67.2 (cost 74.2, Circle features 100, sales tax 0, moving 50).
Where it's strong:
- From Launch up, all six features: courses, a feed, chat in each space, livestreams (20 hours a month, 100 attendees per stream), points, badges and leaderboards, and member apps.
- Web payments run through your own Stripe account, and Launch includes a member list export.
- It costs $888 a year less than Circle Professional at $10,000 a month.
Where it falls short:
- Mighty's docs say paid memberships can't be transferred in directly; it suggests free trials longer than members' remaining paid time.
- Every plan takes a fee on top of Stripe's, and purchases in Mighty's iOS app pay Apple 15%.
- Tax collection runs through a separate Quaderno account, from $24 a month, and you file.
Best suited for: hosts whose community runs on live sessions and events. The Mighty Networks alternatives cover where it falls short.
3. Skool, best for simple, gamified groups with tax handled
Skool pairs a community feed with a classroom, a calendar, live calls, and points and levels that unlock content.
Hobby costs $9 a month plus 10% + 30¢ per sale; Pro costs $99 plus 2.9% + 30¢, or 3.9% on charges above $900, with processing included. Our memberships cost $1,381 a year at $1,000 on Hobby, then $5,403 and $22,261 on Pro, the cheapest here at $50,000.
Our score: 63.6 (cost 84.0, Circle features 50, sales tax 100, moving 0).
Where it's strong:
- Skool is the merchant of record and collects, files and pays sales tax and EU VAT, which Circle leaves to you.
- Unlimited members, courses, videos and live calls on both plans, with Skool Call recording live video in the app or browser.
- Native points, levels and leaderboards.
Where it falls short:
- No group chat: members can message one to one, but there are no chat rooms.
- You can't connect your own Stripe, and Skool documents no subscription import, so every Circle subscriber re-subscribes.
- Growth Boost is on by default and takes 30% of recurring charges from members Skool's Discovery brings you, and prices are USD only.
Best suited for: community-first groups where points and levels drive engagement. Our Skool vs Circle vs Whop comparison goes deeper on all three.
4. Whop, best for the lowest cost with your Stripe subscribers moved
Whop has no monthly plan. Forums, Chat, Courses, built-in livestreams saved for replay and paid Events all attach to one product, and members use Whop's iOS and Android app.
A US card sale costs 2.7% + 30¢, plus a 0.5% Billing fee on subscriptions when it's enabled (our math includes it). Our memberships cost $457, $4,575 and $22,873 a year: the lowest at $1,000 and $10,000 a month, and $4,068 a year less than Circle Professional at $10,000.
Our score: 62.4 (cost 99.7, Circle features 50, sales tax 0, moving 50).
Where it's strong:
- Whop's Stripe migration copies Circle's active card subscriptions with their renewal dates, so members don't re-enter cards.
- The lowest cost here until about $33,000 a month, where Skool Pro's 2.9% catches up.
- Its Discover marketplace has charged a 0% published commission since May 12, 2025.
Where it falls short:
- No native points or leaderboards; third-party apps in Whop's App Store add them.
- Whop holds members' cards afterwards, so leaving later means re-subscribing everyone; new accounts also face a $2,500 per-checkout cap until approved.
- Tax collection is opt-in at 2% of taxed sales and remitted only in the US, EU and UK, and there's no built-in email marketing.
Switching from Circle: only active or trialing card subscriptions with a customer email move, and Stripe emails each customer a cancellation notice, so warn members first. Our free tool creates your products from Circle's audience CSV and adds Forums and Chat; courses are rebuilt in Whop Courses. The Circle to Whop guide has every step.
Best suited for: paid communities that want to keep the most of each payment. If that's you, create a Whop (a referral link: we earn a commission, at no cost to you).
5. Kajabi, best for community plus email marketing and funnels
Kajabi puts the community next to courses, coaching, a website, funnels and email marketing. Basic costs $179 a month, Growth $249 and Pro $499 ($143, $199 and $399 yearly), and Kajabi Payments charges 2.9% to 2.7% + 30¢ by plan, plus 0.7% on subscriptions.
Our memberships cost $2,653, $7,203 and $27,421 a year on Basic: the most here at $1,000 a month, but less than Circle at $10,000 and $50,000.
Our score: 60.7 (cost 57.9, Circle features 100, sales tax 0, moving 50).
Where it's strong:
- All six Circle features we checked, plus unlimited marketing emails, landing pages and funnels, which Circle sells as Email Hub.
- Kajabi migrates active Stripe subscriptions into Kajabi Payments on request, keeping each customer's next charge date.
- A branded app comes with Pro.
Where it falls short:
- One community on Basic and Growth, and Basic stops at 2,500 contacts.
- On Kajabi Payments the cards sit with Kajabi, not in your own Stripe; connecting your own Stripe adds a 2% fee on Basic.
- Kajabi Sales Tax collects tax for $0.15 a sale but doesn't file or remit it.
Best suited for: creators who want the community, courses, email and website in one account. See the Kajabi alternatives for its costs against the field.
6. Discord Server Subscriptions, best for groups that live in Discord
Server Subscriptions is Discord's built-in paywall: monthly tiers tied to roles and channels, with optional free trials, and members subscribe without leaving the app.
There's no monthly fee. Discord's Monetization Terms list a 6% processing fee on desktop and browser purchases and a 10% platform fee on what's left, about 15.4% in total. Our memberships cost $1,848, $18,480 and $92,400 a year, the most here by far.
Our score: 19.9 (cost 12.2, Circle features 0, sales tax 100, moving 0).
Where it's strong:
- No bot, no checkout page and no second account for members.
- Where local law requires, Discord assesses, collects and remits sales tax and VAT.
- No plan fee while a group is small.
Where it falls short:
- Payouts arrive within 45 days after the month ends, after a $100 first payout and monthly server reviews.
- Only owners based in the US with a US bank account and ID can use it.
- No courses or native points, and iPhone purchases add Apple's fee to the buyer's price.
Best suited for: chat-first groups whose members never leave Discord. Our Whop vs Discord breakdown covers the fees in more depth.
Side-by-side comparison
The same four criteria, side by side. Scores are out of 100, and the plan shown is the one used at $10,000 a month.
Prices as of October 2026, from each company's public pricing and help pages, checked October 14, 2026. Plans change, so check before you buy.
| Rank | Platform (plan) | Year at $10,000/mo | Circle features (of 6) | Sales tax | Moving paying members | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Heartbeat (Grow) | $9,003 | 6 | Stripe Tax on memberships; you file | Self-serve Stripe import; your Stripe | 70.8 |
| 2 | Mighty Networks (Launch) | $7,755 | 6 | Quaderno add-on; you file | No import; your Stripe | 67.2 |
| 3 | Skool (Pro) | $5,403 | 5 (no group chat) | Merchant of record | Members re-subscribe | 63.6 |
| 4 | Whop (no plan) | $4,575 | 5 (no native points) | Opt-in service, 2% of taxed sales | Whop's Stripe migration; Whop holds cards after | 62.4 |
| 5 | Kajabi (Basic) | $7,203 | 6 | Collects for $0.15 a sale; you file | Import on request; Kajabi holds cards after | 60.7 |
| 6 | Discord Server Subscriptions | $18,480 | 4 (no courses, no points) | Remitted where required | Members re-subscribe | 19.9 |
| — | Circle Professional, for reference | $8,643 | 6 | Stripe Tax; you file | — | Not scored |
What a year costs on each platform
| Platform (plan used) | $1,000/mo in sales | $10,000/mo | $50,000/mo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whop (no plan) | $457 | $4,575 | $22,873 |
| Skool (Hobby, then Pro) | $1,381 | $5,403 | $22,261 |
| Mighty Networks (Explore, Launch, Growth) | $1,441 | $7,755 | $29,173 |
| Heartbeat (Build, then Grow) | $1,609 | $9,003 | $37,861 |
| Discord Server Subscriptions | $1,848 | $18,480 | $92,400 |
| Kajabi (Basic) | $2,653 | $7,203 | $27,421 |
| Circle (Professional, Business at $50,000), for comparison | $1,933 | $8,643 | $33,901 |
Yearly cost = 12 × (monthly plan price + sales × fee rate + charges × $0.30), where charges = sales ÷ $49, billed monthly, US cards, no taxes, payout fees or optional add-ons. The rates are 3.2% on Whop (2.7% plus its 0.5% Billing fee), 2.9% on Skool Pro and 10% on Hobby (all-in), 7.9%, 4.9% or 3.4% on Mighty Networks Explore, Launch and Growth (its fee plus Stripe's 2.9%), 7.9% or 5.4% on Heartbeat Build and Grow, 3.6% on Kajabi Basic (2.9% plus 0.7% on subscriptions), about 15.4% on Discord with no fixed fee, and 5.6% or 4.6% on Circle (its 2% or 1% plus Stripe's 2.9% and 0.7% Billing). Mighty Networks and Heartbeat don't say whether Stripe Billing's 0.7% applies to their subscriptions; if it does, add $840 a year at $10,000 to each. Run your own numbers in the creator fee calculator.
Which Circle alternative fits your use case
| Your situation | Pick | Runner-up | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Community-first: a few hundred members, everything in one place | Heartbeat | Mighty Networks | All six features, unlimited admins and a free Stripe subscription import |
| Community-first: live cohorts and events | Mighty Networks | Heartbeat | 20 livestream hours a month on Launch, points and member apps |
| Community-first: gamified, with tax handled | Skool | Mighty Networks | Points and levels, and Skool is the merchant of record |
| Storefront: the lowest fees on memberships, with Stripe subscribers moved | Whop | Skool Pro (cheaper above about $33,000 a month) | No plan fee, and Whop's Stripe migration keeps renewal dates |
| Course-first: community next to email and funnels | Kajabi | Heartbeat | Unlimited emails and funnels on every plan |
| Chat-first: members already live in Discord | Discord Server Subscriptions | Whop (its Discord app) | No bot or checkout page; US owners only |
| Build it yourself with code or an AI agent | Whop | Stay on Circle Business | Whop has an API, an MCP server and code-built sites; Circle's Business plan adds its APIs and MCP |
| Brand community with workflows and branded apps | Stay on Circle | Heartbeat (Scale) | Workflows and APIs on Business, branded apps on Circle Plus |
What results look like: a worked example
We don't publish customer results without permission, so this is arithmetic on published fees, not a customer's outcome. Take 200 members at $49 a month ($9,800 a month), US cards.
| Platform (plan) | Plan and fees per month | You keep per month | Cost per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whop | $373.60 | $9,426.40 | $4,483 |
| Skool (Pro) | $443.20 | $9,356.80 | $5,318 |
| Kajabi (Basic) | $591.80 | $9,208.20 | $7,102 |
| Mighty Networks (Launch) | $635.20 | $9,164.80 | $7,622 |
| Circle (Professional) | $707.80 | $9,092.20 | $8,494 |
| Heartbeat (Grow) | $738.20 | $9,061.80 | $8,858 |
| Discord Server Subscriptions | $1,509.20 | $8,290.80 | $18,110 |
Moving that community from Circle Professional to Heartbeat costs $30.40 more a month but keeps every feature and the cards in your Stripe; to Mighty Networks it saves $72.60 a month, and to Whop $334.20 a month, about $4,010 a year, with Circle's card subscribers moved through Whop's Stripe migration. If you gate a Discord or Telegram group through Whop's apps, their listings say they add 3% to that product's payments, which would take Whop to $667.60 a month.
When Circle is the better choice
Staying is the right call if you rely on what Circle does best at the top end: workflows, APIs and an MCP server on Business, branded apps on Circle Plus, and a polished community for a brand. Circle's concierge team also migrates Stripe subscriptions in for free, so if you're consolidating several communities onto one, Circle may be the destination rather than the departure.
If price is the problem, compare yearly billing ($89 instead of $99 on Professional) and Business, whose 1% fee beats Professional's 2% above about $12,000 a month.
Move to Whop free (no passwords)
The Circle side of the move is the same wherever you go. Export your audience CSV and your paywall subscriptions, download course videos, ask Circle support for the posts export if you want an archive, move your subscribers, and only then disconnect Stripe and cancel Circle.
If Whop is your pick, our tool is free and never asks for your Circle or Whop password. Drop your Circle audience export and it creates your products and claim links in your browser, sets up Whop Forums and Chat (old posts stay behind), and lists everything before you sign in to Whop. Card subscribers on your Stripe keep their renewal dates through Whop's Stripe migration. Our guide to moving Circle subscribers covers the order, and MoveToWhop for AI agents shows how to hand the move to your assistant.
Ready when you are: start your free Circle to Whop migration.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Circle alternative in 2026?
On our published criteria, Heartbeat scores highest (70.8 of 100): it has all six community features Circle has and imports your existing Stripe subscriptions for free. Mighty Networks (67.2) is second and costs less, and Skool (63.6) leads on tax, since it's the merchant of record.
What is the cheapest alternative to Circle?
Whop up to about $33,000 a month in $49 memberships: about $4,575 a year at $10,000 a month, against $8,643 on Circle Professional. Above that, Skool Pro costs slightly less, and Discord, with no plan fee, is the most expensive option at about 15.4% of every payment.
How do I move my Circle members without them re-paying?
Circle bills through your own Stripe, so pick a platform that can take over existing Stripe subscriptions: Heartbeat imports them self-serve, Whop's Stripe migration moves active card subscriptions with their renewal dates, and Kajabi migrates them into Kajabi Payments on request. Subscriptions bought in a branded Circle app through Apple or Google can't move, and Mighty Networks, Skool and Discord need members to re-subscribe.
Which Circle alternative is most like Circle?
Mighty Networks and Heartbeat. Both have spaces or channels, chat, courses, live video, points or badges and member apps, both bill through Stripe accounts you own, and both take a plan-based fee on top of Stripe's, as Circle does.
Which Circle alternatives handle sales tax for me?
Skool is the merchant of record and handles sales tax and EU VAT, and Discord remits tax where the law requires it. Whop collects and remits only if you turn on its tax service, at 2% of taxed sales, while Heartbeat, Mighty Networks and Kajabi collect at checkout and leave filing to you, as Circle does.
What is the best free alternative to Circle?
Discord is free to run, and Whop has no monthly fee, only per-sale fees. Circle itself has no free plan, only a 14-day trial with no card required.
Sources
Last updated . Prices and fees checked . Plans change, so confirm on the official page before you buy.
- 1.Circle pricing page and plan comparison table (checked 2026-10-14)circle.so
- 2.Circle Knowledge Base: Paywall transaction fees (checked 2026-10-14)help.circle.so
- 3.Circle Knowledge Base: Export your community data (checked 2026-10-03)help.circle.so
- 4.Circle Knowledge Base: Community storage, overages enforced from November 15, 2025 (checked 2026-10-02)help.circle.so
- 5.Circle Knowledge Base: Circle AI billing and credits, from July 29, 2026 (checked 2026-10-02)help.circle.so
- 6.Wayback Machine: Circle pricing page on February 11, 2025, Basic plan at $39/mo (checked 2026-10-03)web.archive.org
- 7.Heartbeat pricing page: plans, member caps, transaction fees, features, migration FAQ (checked 2026-10-14)heartbeat.chat
- 8.Heartbeat Help: Import and migrate existing Stripe subscriptions (checked 2026-10-14)help.heartbeat.chat
- 9.Mighty Networks pricing page (checked 2026-10-14)mightynetworks.com
- 10.Mighty Networks docs: moving paying members from another platform (checked 2026-10-14)docs.mightynetworks.com
- 11.Skool Payments FAQs: fees, merchant of record, USD, Growth Boost (checked 2026-10-14)help.skool.com
- 12.Whop fees, docs.whop.com (checked 2026-10-14)docs.whop.com
- 13.Whop help: Taxes, opt-in tax service at 2% (checked 2026-10-14)docs.whop.com
- 14.Whop blog: Stripe subscription migrations (checked 2026-10-03)whop.com
- 15.Kajabi pricing page (checked 2026-10-14)kajabi.com
- 16.Kajabi Help: Migrate Stripe subscriptions and payment plans to Kajabi Payments (checked 2026-10-14)help.kajabi.com
- 17.Discord Monetization Terms: 6% processing and 10% platform fee (checked 2026-10-14)support.discord.com
- 18.Discord Creator Revenue FAQ: payouts, minimums, eligibility (checked 2026-10-14)creator-support.discord.com
What changed
- Re-ranked on four published criteria (yearly cost on $49 memberships at $1,000, $10,000 and $50,000 a month, Circle features covered, sales tax handling, moving paying members) instead of a hand-picked order. Heartbeat moves from fourth to first, Mighty Networks from third to second, and Whop from first to fourth: it costs the least but has no native points and keeps members' cards. Dropped Bettermode, which sells no paid access. Cost example switched from $40 to $49 memberships at three revenue levels. Re-checked every plan price. Added key takeaways, scores, a use-case table and a worked example.
- First published. Prices and fees checked October 3, 2026.
Keep reading
Related guides and comparisons
Circle to Whop
Circle paywalls bill through your own Stripe, so Whop Migrations can move card subscribers with their renewal dates. See what else moves and the 8-step plan.
Best paid community platforms
We ranked 8 paid community platforms on fees at $1k to $20k a month, engagement features, switching, tax and payouts. Whop is #1 at 3.8% of revenue.
Whop vs Circle
Circle costs $89 to $419/mo plus a 1% to 2% fee on top of Stripe; Whop is $0/mo plus 2.7% + 30¢. See costs at $1k, $10k and $50k/mo, and when Circle wins.
Skool vs Circle vs Whop
Skool vs Circle: $9 or $99/mo plus 10% or 2.9%, or $89 to $419/mo plus up to 2% over Stripe. Whop: $0/mo, 2.7% + 30¢ per US card sale. Costs at $1k, $10k, $50k.
Mighty Networks alternatives
Mighty Networks alternatives scored on yearly cost, community features, sales tax and moving paying members: Whop, Skool, Circle, Heartbeat, Kajabi and Podia.
Move Circle subscribers
Circle paywalls bill through your own Stripe, so Whop Migrations can copy card subscriptions and renewal dates. Exclude installments; cancel Circle's plan last.
Bet on yourself. Move to Whop.
Free migration. Takes minutes. Keep your members, courses and revenue.
