---
title: "How to move a Memberful Discord community to Whop without kicking anyone"
description: "Memberful's bot can kick or strip roles from members who stop paying on Memberful. Give Whop its own roles, switch to All members, and handle Discourse too."
url: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-discord-to-whop
updated: 2026-10-14
author: MoveToWhop
---

# How to move a Memberful Discord community to Whop without kicking anyone

URL: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-discord-to-whop
Type: Guide · Updated 2026-10-14 · Facts checked 2026-10-14

> **Quick answer:** Your Discord server stays; only the bot that hands out paid roles changes. Before any cancelled Memberful subscription expires, switch Memberful's Discord access to All members, or its bot removes lapsed members from the server. Give Whop new roles, because Memberful can strip its plan roles from anyone who doesn't qualify on Memberful. Put Whop Bot at the top, test with a second account, and retire Memberful's roles last.

*We built MoveToWhop, the free migration tool mentioned in this guide, and we may earn a referral commission from Whop if you create a Whop through our links. It costs you nothing. Memberful's and Whop's Discord steps below were checked October 14, 2026.*

The server doesn't move. Only the bot that hands out paid roles changes, and both bots can run side by side while members switch. The risk is one Memberful setting: left as it is, Memberful's bot can remove people from your server the day their Memberful subscription ends, even if they're paying you on Whop by then. This guide covers the Discord part, and Discourse at the end. The [full Memberful to Whop plan](https://movetowhop.com/memberful-to-whop) covers plans, members and fees.

## How Memberful's bot treats members who leave

Memberful's Discord integration has two access settings. Which one you picked decides what happens as members cancel on Memberful and their subscriptions expire:

*Memberful's Discord rules as of October 2026. Sources at the end of this page.*

| Memberful setting | Who can be in the server | When a Memberful subscription lapses |
|---|---|---|
| All members | Anyone with a Memberful account: active, inactive or free | Memberful removes its plan roles; the member stays in the server |
| Members with an active subscription | Active members only | Memberful removes the member from the server |

Three more rules from Memberful's docs matter here:

- **Plan roles are Memberful's.** Each plan can have an Active role and a Trial role. Memberful warns that any role mapped to a plan may be removed from people who had it, unless their Memberful membership qualifies them for it.
- **Hand-given roles don't stick.** Memberful says not to assign roles manually: if your integration settings change, it may remove them on its next sync. Switching to All members, below, is a settings change.
- **Changes take a while.** Syncing runs in the background, and role updates can take 10 minutes or more on a big server.

So if Whop's bot gives out the same "Member" role, Memberful takes it away from everyone who stopped paying on Memberful. And on the active-only setting, Memberful kicks them. Separate roles and the All members setting fix both.

## Before you start

- **Discord admin access,** to create roles and edit channel permissions.
- **Your member export.** Memberful's member export has a Discord User ID column for every member who connected Discord. Our [Memberful export guide](https://movetowhop.com/how-to/export-members-from-memberful) covers the export.
- **One Whop product per Memberful plan.** Each plan's role attaches to its own product. If you haven't moved your plans yet, the free [Memberful migration tool](https://movetowhop.com/migrate?from=memberful) creates one product per plan through Whop's official API.
- **The 3% question.** Whop's fee page lists no Discord fee, but the Discord app's listing says adding it to a product subjects that product's payments to a 3% fee (both checked October 14, 2026). On a $15 plan that's 45 cents a payment. Budget for it until Whop settles it.

## Step 1: Switch Memberful's Discord access to All members

In Memberful, open **Content**, then **Community**, then **Discord**, and click **Settings** (or **Edit settings**). Note which role each plan maps to: you'll recreate those for Whop. If access is set to **Members with an active subscription**, change it to **All members** and click **Update settings**.

Do this before the first subscription you or a member cancels reaches its expiration date. That can be days after your announcement: a cancelled Memberful subscription ends at its next renewal date, and some members renew this week.

The trade-off: under All members, people who stop paying on Memberful and never join Whop stay in your server, without paid roles. You can remove them by hand at the end.

Here's the plan move these roles attach to, in the wizard (about 20 seconds, test data, no sound):

Video: [Memberful to Whop with MoveToWhop](https://movetowhop.com/videos/memberful-to-whop) (22-second demo with test data, transcript on the page)

## Step 2: Create a Whop role for each plan

In Discord, click your server name, then **Server Settings**, then **Roles**, then **Create role**. Make one per Memberful plan and name it so you can tell the bots' roles apart, for example "Member (Whop)" next to Memberful's "Member".

For every private channel a Memberful plan role can see, add the matching Whop role with the same permissions. Check each one before anyone claims it, or members get a role that opens nothing.

## Step 3: Add the Discord app to each Whop product

In your Whop dashboard, per Whop's own guide:

1. Click **Add app** in your whop's sidebar, find Discord in the App Store and click **Add**.
2. Choose **Continue with Discord**.
3. Click **Edit** at the top right of the Discord app, then **Connect Discord**.
4. Pick your server from the dropdown, click **Continue**, then **Authorize**.

## Step 4: Put both bots above the roles they manage

A Discord bot can only manage roles ranked below its own. Whop says its bot's role, **Whop Bot**, has to be at the top of your role list. Memberful's docs say its bot must sit above every role mapped to a Memberful plan.

In **Server Settings**, then **Roles**, arrange them like this, then click **Save Changes**:

1. Whop Bot
2. Memberful's bot role
3. Your plan roles, Memberful's and Whop's

Leave Memberful's bot permissions alone: it needs Manage Roles, Kick Members and Create Invite, and Memberful says the integration malfunctions without any of them. Its bot shows as offline; Memberful says that's normal.

## Step 5: Pick the Whop role and the cancellation action

In the Discord app on Whop, open the **Roles** tab, click **Add Role** and pick the plan's Whop role. If it's not in the list, click **Refetch roles**.

Then open the **Settings** tab. Under **Cancellation actions**, Whop offers No Action, Remove Role, Kick User and Remove All Roles. During the switch, pick **Remove Role**:

- **Kick User** would throw out a member who lets Whop lapse while still paying on Memberful.
- **Remove All Roles** would take their Memberful role too.

The same tab can give past-due members a role of their own. Once Memberful is closed, you can change the cancellation action to Kick User if you want lapsed members out.

## Step 6: Test with a second account

Use a second Whop and Discord account. Claim access through your own link, check that the Whop role appears and the private channels open, then cancel and check that only the Whop role goes. Do this before you send a single invite.

## Step 7: Tell members how to claim their role

Members claim their role themselves, because Whop's API can't add members directly ("checkout does that for you," per Whop's developer docs). Add three lines to your announcement:

1. Join Whop with your link.
2. Connect your Discord account on Whop and click **Claim Access** to get your new role.
3. Your Memberful role disappears when your Memberful subscription ends. That's expected: your Whop role opens the same channels.

To see who hasn't claimed, compare your server's members with the Discord User ID column in your Memberful export, and paste an ID into Memberful's member search to see whose it is. Our [Memberful double-billing guide](https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-subscribers-without-double-billing) covers the rest of the message: each member's first Whop charge date and how to cancel on Memberful.

## Step 8: Retire the Memberful side

When the last Memberful subscription you care about has expired:

1. **Delete the old Memberful plan roles** in Server Settings, then Roles. Memberful's docs don't say what turning off the integration does to roles it already handed out, so remove them yourself.
2. **Turn off the integration** in Memberful under Content, then Community, then Discord.
3. **Remove Memberful's bot** from your server.
4. **Clean up:** remove anyone who never moved, if you don't want them, and switch Whop's cancellation action to Kick User.

## Running Discourse instead?

Memberful signs members into Discourse with single sign-on and maps each plan to a Discourse group. Its docs say that when a member's subscription expires, Memberful removes them from that group, even if they keep their Discourse account. So as members cancel on Memberful to move, they lose your protected categories.

We found no Discourse integration in Whop's docs, so pick one of two paths before the first cancelled subscription expires:

- **Move the discussion to Whop Forums.** Move to Whop sets up Forums and Chat. Copy or pin the threads worth keeping (our [Memberful posts guide](https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-posts-to-whop) covers copying), and keep Discourse as a read-only archive or close it.
- **Keep Discourse and run access yourself.** Turn off the integration in Memberful under Content, then Community, then Discourse. Memberful then tries to turn off its single sign-on, and members sign in to Discourse directly. Those who only ever signed in through Memberful may need Discourse's password reset. If you're locked out, Memberful's docs point to `https://forum.yoursite.com/u/admin-login`. From then on, you add and remove group members in Discourse by hand.

If your community is on Circle or Bettermode, those integrations were built by Circle and Bettermode, not Memberful, so check their own settings before members' Memberful subscriptions lapse. Slack has no Memberful integration, so nothing there changes automatically.

## Troubleshooting

| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| A member who moved to Whop was removed from the server | Memberful's access setting was Members with an active subscription | Switch to All members, then send them your server invite |
| The Whop role vanishes minutes after it's claimed | Whop and Memberful share the role | Give Whop its own role, and remove the shared one from Whop's Roles tab |
| A role isn't in Whop's list | The role list is out of date | Click Refetch roles in the Discord app |
| Whop can't assign a role | Whop Bot sits below that role | Drag Whop Bot to the top of Server Settings, then Roles |
| Memberful roles still show after the move | Memberful doesn't say it cleans up when disconnected | Delete the old Memberful roles by hand |
| Discourse members lost access after cancelling Memberful | Memberful removes expired members from Discourse groups | Turn off the Discourse integration and manage groups in Discourse, or move to Whop Forums |

## Finish: your community live on Whop

Switch Memberful to All members, give Whop its own roles, test once, then announce. Members claim their Whop role, Memberful's roles fall away as subscriptions expire, and you retire Memberful's bot last. Our [guide to running a paid Discord server on Whop](https://movetowhop.com/guides/paid-discord-server-with-whop) covers the Whop side in more depth.

Prefer an AI assistant? Connect MoveToWhop's free read-only MCP server (`https://movetowhop.com/mcp`) and ask it for a Memberful plan; our [Memberful AI migration guide](https://movetowhop.com/memberful-to-whop#ai-agent) has the prompt. Or [start your free Memberful migration](https://movetowhop.com/migrate?from=memberful) now.

## FAQs

### Can I keep my Discord server when I leave Memberful?

Yes. The server is yours. Memberful's bot only invites members, hands out the roles you mapped to each plan and, on one setting, removes lapsed members. Moving to Whop changes which bot does that, not the server, its channels or its message history.

### Will Memberful kick members who move to Whop?

It can. With Members with an active subscription selected, Memberful removes members from your server when their subscription lapses, including people who now pay on Whop. With All members selected, they stay and only lose their Memberful roles. Switch to All members before the first cancelled subscription expires.

### Can Memberful's bot and Whop's bot run in the same server?

Yes, if they don't share roles. Memberful warns that roles mapped to a plan may be removed from anyone whose Memberful membership doesn't qualify, and that roles assigned by hand can be removed on the next sync after a settings change. Give Whop its own roles with the same channel permissions.

### Does Whop charge extra for Discord access?

Whop's sources disagree. Its fee page lists no Discord fee, but the Discord app's listing says adding it to a product subjects that product's payments to a 3% fee (both checked October 14, 2026). Even with it, Whop's 2.7%, 0.5% billing and 3% come to 6.2% plus $0.30 a payment, under Memberful's 4.9% plus Stripe's 2.9% and $0.30, before Memberful's $49 a month.

### What if my Memberful community is on Discourse, not Discord?

Memberful signs members into Discourse and removes them from your Discourse groups when their subscription expires. We found no Discourse integration in Whop's docs, so either move discussions to Whop Forums, or turn off Memberful's integration before members' subscriptions expire and manage Discourse access yourself.

## Sources

- [Memberful docs: Integrate Discord with Memberful, access settings, plan roles and bot permissions (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/docs/community/discord/discord-integrate)
- [Memberful docs: Discord post-setup, role hierarchy, sync timing and manual roles (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/docs/community/discord/discord-post-setup)
- [Memberful docs: Integrate Discourse with Memberful, groups, SSO and disabling (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/docs/community/other-integrations/discourse)
- [Memberful docs: Paid community guide, Discord, Discourse, Circle, Bettermode, bbPress and Slack (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/docs/overview/setup-guides/paid-community)
- [Memberful docs: Export data, Discord User ID column (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/docs/metrics-and-analytics/compare-and-export/export-data)
- [Whop blog: How to connect Discord to Whop, steps, Whop Bot role and cancellation actions (published 2026-04-16, checked 2026-10-14)](https://whop.com/blog/link-whop-to-discord/)
- [Whop app listing: Discord, 3% fee notice (checked 2026-10-14)](https://whop.com/apps/app_sWtSR8DZsEGryg/)
- [Whop Docs: Fees, 2.7% + $0.30 domestic cards, 0.5% billing, no Discord line (checked 2026-10-14)](https://docs.whop.com/payments-and-billing/fees/fees)
- [Whop Docs: Memberships developer guide, checkout creates memberships (checked 2026-10-14)](https://docs.whop.com/developer/guides/memberships)
- [Memberful pricing page, $49 a month plus 4.9% (checked 2026-10-14)](https://memberful.com/pricing)
- [Stripe pricing, 2.9% + 30¢ per domestic card charge (checked 2026-10-14)](https://stripe.com/pricing)

## Related

- https://movetowhop.com/memberful-to-whop
- https://movetowhop.com/guides/paid-discord-server-with-whop
- https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-subscribers-without-double-billing
- https://movetowhop.com/how-to/export-members-from-memberful
- https://movetowhop.com/best/paid-discord-platforms
- https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-posts-to-whop

---
MoveToWhop is independent and not affiliated with Whop, Inc. We may earn a referral commission from Whop when you create a Whop through our links.

Open this page: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-memberful-discord-to-whop
