---
title: "How to move Circle paying members to Whop without double billing"
description: "Circle paywalls bill through your own Stripe, so Whop Migrations can copy card subscriptions and renewal dates. Exclude installments; cancel Circle's plan last."
url: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-circle-subscribers-to-whop
updated: 2026-10-14
author: MoveToWhop
---

# How to move Circle paying members to Whop without double billing

URL: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-circle-subscribers-to-whop
Type: Guide · Updated 2026-10-14 · Facts checked 2026-10-14

> **Quick answer:** Circle paywalls bill through a Stripe business in your name, so Whop Migrations can copy active and trialing card subscriptions of $1 or more with the same price and renewal date, then schedule the old ones to cancel. Exclude installment plans, pause any Circle automation that reacts to cancellations, and send re-join links to everyone the report skips. Cancelling your Circle plan doesn't stop member billing, so close it last.

## Before you start

Circle is one of the few platforms where paying members can move to Whop without typing in a card again. Circle never holds the cards: paywalls run on a Standard Stripe account in your name, and that's exactly what Whop Migrations reads. The risk isn't the copy. It's the order you do things in.

You'll need:

- Admin access to Circle.
- The login for the Stripe account Circle's paywalls use.
- A Whop with your products set up. The free [Circle to Whop migration tool](https://movetowhop.com/migrate?from=circle) creates them.
- Your subscriptions export from Circle, covered in our guide to [exporting Circle members](https://movetowhop.com/how-to/export-members-from-circle).

*We built MoveToWhop and may earn a referral fee from Whop if you create a Whop through our links. Whop Migrations is Whop's own tool; we only link to it.*

## Who moves how

Sort your paying members into these groups before anything runs. Each group takes a different path, and mixing them up is how people get charged twice or lose access.

*Paths as of October 2026, from Circle's help center and Whop's Migrations announcement. Sources at the end of this page.*

| Circle member | What Whop Migrations does | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Card subscription bought on the web, active or trialing, $1 or more | Copies the card, price, billing cycle and renewal date, then schedules the old Stripe subscription to cancel at period end | Warn them about Stripe's cancellation email |
| Paying with Stripe Link, ACH or SEPA | Skips them | Re-join link with a trial that ends on their Circle renewal |
| Past due | Skips them | Re-join link, or let your Stripe failed-payment settings end it |
| Trial started without a card (from an invite or a member profile) | Has no card to copy, so expect it in the not-moved list | Re-join link with the trial's remaining days |
| Installment plan with payments left | Whop's announcement doesn't cover installments | Exclude them and let them finish on Circle, or move them to a Whop split-pay link |
| Subscribed inside your branded iOS or Android app | Can't see them: Apple or Google bills them, not your Stripe | They cancel in their phone settings and re-join |
| One-time paywall, or installments completed | Nothing to bill | Free claim link |

## Step 1: Export your Circle subscriptions

Click **Payments**, then **Subscriptions**. Export the **Active** tab with **All columns** (Circle emails it within a few minutes). Then use the **Status** filter on the All tab to see who is trialing or past due, and the **Details** view on any member to see their renewal date and any coupon applied.

This list is your source of truth for the rest of the move. Whop's report will tell you who moved; this file tells you who should have.

## Step 2: Find the Stripe business Circle uses

If you had Stripe before Circle, Circle didn't connect that account directly. It created a new business under your Stripe login, and all paywall activity lives in that business only.

Sign in to Stripe and click the business name in the top-left corner to switch businesses. You're in the right one when its Subscriptions page lists your Circle members. Keep that business open: Whop asks for its publishable and secret keys (Developers, then API keys), and you'll add Whop's email to its team.

Video: [Circle to Whop with MoveToWhop](https://movetowhop.com/videos/circle-to-whop) (22-second demo with test data, transcript on the page)

## Step 3: Set up your Whop products first

Each subscription Whop moves needs a product and plan to land on. Run the [free migration tool](https://movetowhop.com/migrate?from=circle): tap Circle, drop your Circle CSVs on the Members row, check the paywall names and prices Sync found, then press **Move to Whop** and approve on Whop's sign-in page.

Card subscribers are left to Whop Migrations by default and show as "via Stripe migration" with no link. Switch subscribers on in Review as well, and the tool also creates a hidden plan at each member's current price with a free trial that ends on their next Circle renewal. You'll send that link only to the members Whop's report says it didn't move.

## Step 4: Pause anything on Circle that reacts to cancellations

Whop Migrations schedules every moved Stripe subscription to cancel at the end of its current period. To Circle, that can look like a wave of cancellations.

Circle has no built-in cancellation email, but its help center suggests two workarounds: a workflow that emails or DMs a member when a cancellation starts, and a Zapier zap on "Member canceled subscription". If you run either, turn it off before you start, or every member you move may get a "sorry to see you go" message on the same day. Turn it back on after the move if you still need it.

## Step 5: Tell members before you start

Two emails will reach every moved member: Stripe's notice that their old subscription is set to cancel, and billing emails from Whop. Tell them both are coming and that nothing about their price or renewal date changes. Card updates should happen before you start, because Whop skips payment-method changes made after the transfer begins.

Our [migration announcement templates](https://movetowhop.com/guides/migration-announcement-templates) have a version for Stripe-migrated members and one for members who re-join.

## Step 6: Run Whop Migrations, excluding installments

1. On the tool's Done screen, click **Move paying subscribers**, or in Whop go to **Settings**, then **Migrations**, then **Stripe**.
2. Enter the publishable and secret keys for Circle's Stripe business. You type them into Whop's dashboard; they never pass through MoveToWhop.
3. Copy the Whop email shown on screen and add it to that Stripe business's team with the **Data migration specialist** role.
4. Review the preview scan. Paste the emails or Stripe subscription IDs of your installment members into the exclusion list, plus anyone else you want to handle yourself.
5. Check one member with a Circle coupon in the preview. Whop's preview lists each subscription's amount, but its announcement doesn't mention coupons, so confirm that amount before you start.
6. Start the migration and download the CSV report.

### Why installments stay out

A Circle installment plan is a one-time price split into equal payments. When the last one clears, Circle marks it Completed and the member keeps access for good. Whop's announcement doesn't say a copied subscription stops after a set number of payments, so a moved installment plan could keep billing. Excluding them removes that risk.

You then have two choices:

- **Let them finish on Circle.** Keep Circle running until the final installment clears. Give them Whop access now with a hidden free checkout link on the same product (Whop Dashboard, then Checkout links: untick **Show on store page** and set **Stock** to the number of installment members). If an installment fails, Circle cancels the plan, so end their Whop access too (Users, then Memberships, then Terminate membership).
- **Move them to Whop split pay.** Create a hidden recurring checkout link with **Enable split pay (Installments)**, the same payment amount and the number of payments left. The first Whop payment is charged when the member joins, so send the link shortly before their next Circle installment is due. Once they've joined, cancel their Circle installment plan (admins can only cancel installments immediately) before that date.

## Step 7: Send re-join links to everyone the report skipped

Put Circle's active list next to Whop's report. Anyone active in Circle who isn't marked as moved goes on the re-join path: Link, ACH and SEPA payers, past-due members, card-less trials and app-store subscribers.

Send each one the trial link from Step 3. Its trial ends on their Circle renewal date, so their first Whop charge lands when Circle's would have. If someone joins late and their trial is too short, open their membership in Whop (Users, then Memberships, then the three-dot menu) and use **Add free days** to push the next charge back.

App-store members need one extra instruction. Circle can't cancel or refund Apple purchases for a member, and can't cancel Google ones either, so they cancel in their phone's subscription settings, then join through the link.

## Step 8: Cancel leftover Circle subscriptions at period end

Leave the subscriptions Whop already scheduled alone. For each member who re-joins:

1. In Circle, click **Payments**, then **Subscriptions**.
2. Click **More actions** (three dots) beside the member and choose **Cancel**.
3. Pick **End of current period**. They keep access until their paid time runs out, and the subscription doesn't renew.

Don't use **Cancel immediately** for these members. It cuts access at once and can't be undone. Circle's Business plan and higher include workflows (Professional has none), and a bulk-action workflow with the **Cancel paywall subscription** action can do this for a whole list.

Every renewal still billed through Circle pays Circle's transaction fee (2% on Professional, 1% on Business and Scale, 0.5% on Circle Plus) on top of Stripe's, so it's worth getting the stragglers across in the first cycle.

## Step 9: Close Circle last

Cancelling your Circle plan doesn't cancel your members' paywall subscriptions, and your Stripe business stays connected to Circle afterwards. So close in this order:

1. Wait until the last subscription you didn't move has ended or been cancelled, and the last installment has cleared. For monthly members that's one more billing cycle. If you have annual members, ask Circle support how cancelling your plan affects subscriptions already scheduled to end.
2. Email support@circle.so for the full data export (members, spaces, posts and comments as four CSVs) if you want an archive. Circle typically removes community data about 90 days after the plan ends.
3. Click the community name or logo, then **Settings**. Under **Subscription**, pick **Plans**, scroll down and click **End your subscription**. The community stays up until the end of your current Circle billing cycle.
4. Once every member subscription is settled, you can close the Stripe business Circle created, if you want to. Circle advises against reusing it for anything else.

## Timeline at a glance

| When | Do this |
|---|---|
| 14 days before | Export subscriptions, sort members into the groups above, announce the move |
| 7 days before | Set up Whop products, pause cancellation workflows and zaps, ask members to update cards now |
| Move day | Run Whop Migrations with installments excluded, download the report, send re-join and claim links |
| Days 1 to 31 | Cancel each re-joining member's Circle subscription at period end; chase anyone who hasn't joined |
| After the last old period ends | Request Circle's data export, then cancel your Circle plan |

## Do it with your AI agent

An agent can plan this with you and check the numbers, but it should never hold your Stripe keys. Connect MoveToWhop's read-only MCP server and ask for the Circle plan with your own Stripe:

```bash
claude mcp add --transport http movetowhop https://movetowhop.com/mcp
```

Then ask: "Run get_migration_plan for circle with uses_own_stripe true and walk me through the payments step." You still enter the keys in Whop's dashboard yourself. Our [Circle agent guide](https://movetowhop.com/circle-to-whop#ai-agent) has the full run, and [moving subscriptions to Whop](https://movetowhop.com/guides/migrate-subscriptions-to-whop) covers the same flow for other platforms.

## Troubleshooting

| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| The preview finds no subscriptions | You entered keys for the wrong Stripe business | Switch to the business Circle created (top-left in Stripe) and use its keys |
| A member is missing from the preview | Link, ACH or SEPA payment, past due, under $1, or no email on the Stripe customer | Add the missing email in Stripe and run again (Whop skips what it already moved), or send a re-join link |
| Members got a cancellation message from Circle | A workflow or zap fires on cancellations | Pause it, and send a short "you're all set on Whop" note |
| A moved installment member is still billed after their last payment | The plan wasn't excluded, and the copy doesn't know the payment count | Refund the extra charge, cancel that membership's billing in Whop, and send a free claim link so their access continues |
| A re-joining member was charged twice | Their Circle subscription wasn't cancelled before its renewal | Refund one charge, cancel Circle at period end, and check others with the same renewal date |
| Charges continue after you closed Circle | The plan was cancelled before the member subscriptions | Cancel the remaining subscriptions in Stripe, or ask Circle support for help |

## Next step: your paying members on Whop

Start with the [free Circle migration tool](https://movetowhop.com/migrate?from=circle): it sets up the products your subscribers land on and opens Whop Migrations from its Done screen. For everything else that moves, from courses to Forums, see our full [Circle to Whop guide](https://movetowhop.com/circle-to-whop). Not sure Whop is the right destination? Our [Circle alternatives](https://movetowhop.com/alternatives/circle) page compares seven options on price and fees.

## FAQs

### Do Circle members have to re-enter their card on Whop?

Not if they pay by card on the web. Circle paywalls bill through a Stripe business you own, so Whop Migrations copies their saved card with the same price, billing cycle and renewal date. Members paying with Stripe Link, ACH or SEPA, past-due members, and anyone who subscribed inside a branded iPhone or Android app re-join through a link instead.

### If I cancel my Circle plan, do my members stop being charged?

No. Circle's help center says cancelling your community plan won't cancel your members' paywall subscriptions, and your Stripe business stays connected to Circle. Any subscription Whop Migrations didn't move keeps renewing in Stripe until you cancel it. Cancel those at period end first, then cancel the plan.

### What happens to Circle installment plans?

Whop's Migrations announcement doesn't mention installments, so exclude those members and let them finish paying on Circle, which keeps Circle running until the final installment clears. Give them Whop access meanwhile with a hidden free checkout link. For long plans, a hidden Whop split-pay link with the remaining number of payments is the other option.

### Can I just ask Circle to disconnect Stripe?

Not as a shortcut. Circle disconnects Stripe only through support, and only after you cancel every active member subscription and installment plan. Cancelling before Whop Migrations runs would leave it nothing to copy, because it only picks up active and trialing subscriptions. After the move you usually don't need to disconnect at all.

### Will a member be charged by both Circle and Whop?

Not if you follow the order here. Whop schedules each moved Stripe subscription to cancel at the end of its current period and bills on the old renewal date. For members who re-join, the free trial on their Whop link ends on their Circle renewal date, and you cancel their Circle subscription at period end once they've joined.

## Sources

- [Whop blog: Whop Migrations, published June 17, 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://whop.com/blog/migrations/)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Supported Stripe account types, paywalls use a Standard account you own, updated November 10, 2025 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-setup/understanding-supported-stripe-account-types-for-circle-paywalls)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Connect a Stripe account for paywalls, sub-account and disconnecting, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-setup/connect-a-stripe-account-for-paywalls)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Export member subscriptions and transactions data, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-management/export-member-subscriptions-and-transactions-data)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: View all member subscriptions, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-management/view-all-member-subscriptions)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Cancel member subscriptions, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-management/cancel-member-subscriptions)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Offer installment pricing options for paywalls, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-setup/offer-installment-pricing-options-for-paywalls)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: In-app purchases overview, updated March 1, 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/branded-apps/in-app-purchases/in-app-purchases-overview)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Paywall notifications from Circle and Stripe, cancellation workarounds, updated August 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/payments/paywall-management/understanding-paywall-notifications)
- [Circle Knowledge Base: Canceling your community plan, updated October 2026 (checked 2026-10-14)](https://help.circle.so/p/administration/account/canceling-your-community-plan)
- [Circle pricing page, transaction fee and workflows by plan (checked 2026-10-14)](https://circle.so/pricing)
- [Whop Docs: Create a checkout link, stock, store-page visibility and split payments (checked 2026-10-14)](https://docs.whop.com/manage-your-business/payment-processing/create-checkout-link)
- [Whop Docs: Free trials, recurring links only (checked 2026-10-14)](https://docs.whop.com/manage-your-business/products/free-trials)
- [Whop Docs: Manage users, Add free days and Terminate membership (checked 2026-10-14)](https://docs.whop.com/manage-your-business/manage-payments/manage-users)

## Related

- https://movetowhop.com/circle-to-whop
- https://movetowhop.com/guides/migrate-subscriptions-to-whop
- https://movetowhop.com/stripe-to-whop
- https://movetowhop.com/how-to/export-members-from-circle
- https://movetowhop.com/guides/migration-announcement-templates
- https://movetowhop.com/pricing/circle

---
MoveToWhop is independent and not affiliated with Whop, Inc. We may earn a referral commission from Whop when you create a Whop through our links.

Open this page: https://movetowhop.com/guides/move-circle-subscribers-to-whop
